My personal review of Halo Wars(the game, not the demo)

Last post 02-27-2009, 11:35 AM by JJ (JumpingJet). 1158 replies.
Page 1 of 78 (1,159 items)   1 2 3 4 5 Next > ... Last »
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  02-14-2009, 3:31 PM 470025

    My personal review of Halo Wars(the game, not the demo)

    To start things off, yes I have the full game.  You don't believe me, that's fine, you don't have to read this then, and pretend it doesn't exist.  For those of you who do believe I have the game, here is my review of it.  And no, its not all "its the best game evar" or "it suks" but somewhere in the middle...

    Let me first say this, the 07 demo is gone, and you people need to let go.  Stop being clingy little bastards and just put the 07 into the back of your mind.  What you see, is what you get.  Also, stop comparing Halo Wars to Starcraft, DoW, and other RTS games.  Halo is different, get over it.

    I also should add that this review is a little biased.  Other people may not have been so...nice.

     Lets start with the controls shall we?

    controls

    Ya, ya, I bet you've heard enough of the controls so here is my take on it.  You have to be missing your left hand, and have a hook for your right hand in order not to get the controls.  Even then, the controls should be simple enough to use.

     

    Next up is campaign

    Campaign

    Let me start off with a question on this one.  ES, wtf?  Honestly, I don't know what you guys were thinking when you made the campaign.  Don't get me wrong, you guys were good(to some degree) with the canon.  I don't know what happened... Either you guys dropped the canon into a few thousand pieces, and tried to piece it back together with glue and scotch tape... And you seem to be forgeting the closer part with certain vehicles and units.  Graheme once said as an example "The reason you don't see wolverines is because the factory was on Mars, and that factory was bombed in 2535 blah blah blah...".  Either you guys forgot to add the reasons, or I'm not looking hard enough.  Maybe the answers are in the black boxes that are scattered throughout the campaign, so I could be wrong there.  Anyway, to get on a good note, the campaign is atleast fun.  To make a long story longer, this campaign is only for a select few groups.  If you like fun, and are not much into story telling, you'll have a blast playing the campaign.  If you're one of those people who only played halo 3, never read any of the books, and basically know nothing of the story, like RTS games, you should like this campaign.  If you like to watch things crash and burn, then you should also play the campaign.  Also, you achievement whores should like the campaign, as most of the achievements are there. 

    Now, here are the people who should avoid the campaign.  People who have an overly obsetion with the halo story line, that a single inconsistancy will send you into a frenzy and killing spree.  If you like a good story that makes sense, stay away from this.  If you are one of those achievement whores who are also a fan of the halo story, you'll more than likely tear yourself in two unsure if you should do the campaign or not.  Although, you could always play co-op and have the other guy do all the work while you do something else.

    Let me sum up those two paragraphs with this.  If you like the halo story, then avoid this campaign.  If you like fun, achievements, and don't care for the halo story, you'll enjoy the campaign. 

     

    Cutscenes

    These are amazing, whoever worked on the cutsenes needs a pat-on-the back, or give them a raise, or something even better.  If you need a reason to play the campaign, it's because of the cutscenes.  They literarly blew me away...

     

    skirmish

    This, is what I feel the best part of the game(besides MP).  The maps vary from size and certain objects on the map.  They are a hell of a lot of fun to play, and there is serious re-playablity here(unlike campaign).  To those that have the demo and played against the AI, I'm thinking you thought the AI was easy right?  Well, the Legendary AI is more than a challenge.  Plus, there is another difficulty level called automatic(40), which I assume means "In 40 seconds, you better have brought the lube".  I was a little disappointed with the inclusion of only two gametypes, standard and deathmatch.  Maybe some DLC will be some new gametypes, I hope.

    To make this a short post, skirmish is fun, and there is serious enjoyment to be had in these maps.

    Multiplayer

    I can't really say much on this, as I have only tried twice to find a match, and both times I was the only one online.  Maybe they were avoiding me because I am so awesome, that they didn't want to lose to me, or I just get on at the wrong times.  I assume its the first.  Anyway, if it's anything like skirmish, except with more people, then it will be even more fun than skirmish.

     Halo Timeline

    This is the cool part right here, the halo timeline.  What it is, is the events that occuried throughout and before the human-covenant war.  The irony that I find is that those events hold more canon credibility than the campaign, which is what you need to do in order to find these events.  Irony is a funny thing isn't it?  Anyway, they are pretty cool, and adds a nice backstory to the halo universe.

     

    Let me sum it all up in these last few sentences.  The game is fun, hell of a lot of fun.  It falls short on the story though.  You'll spend most of your time on the skirmish rather than the campaign. 

    If you're looking for a rating, here it is.  Its good, but not awesome.  You want a number rating, Q.  I don't see the need for numbers, but if you want one, its about a 7, maybe 7.5.

    All in all, this is a game you want to play with or agianst friends, rather than tell you a compelling story that makes sense.  You can always wait for the price to go down to get this game.  Maybe a month or two.

    anyway, if you have any questions, feel free to ask me at anytime.  I probably missed some stuff in this review, so feel free to point out anything.


    MY POST COUNT IS OVER 9,000!!!
    Bow before me mortals!
    banned, for no good reason. I will be back though, and I intend to kick some serious ass...
  •  02-14-2009, 3:39 PM 470029 in reply to 470025

    Re: My personal review of Halo Wars(the game, not the demo)

    Thanks for the review. Quite well written.

    One thing though-you mentioned something about black boxes and the Halo Timeline, the latter I recall being linked to an achievement. Is it a case of unlocking aspects of the timeline by finding these boxes, kind of like Command and Conquer 3 except unlocking info based on location rather than the completion of objectives? Or is there a different system?

    If the campaign's as you say, I'd like to keep an eye out for such things on the first playthrough.

    Anyway, thanks again.

  •  02-14-2009, 3:40 PM 470030 in reply to 470025

    Re: My personal review of Halo Wars(the game, not the demo)

    Nice review felix!
    I...I am a Monument of your sins

    Gravemind

    I..I am taking the fight to the N O o B s!!!!

    -flipyap the leader of all of the grunts


  •  02-14-2009, 3:40 PM 470031 in reply to 470025

    Re: My personal review of Halo Wars(the game, not the demo)

    Perfect review! Nicely done Felix.

     

    Q: So ya tried the 3v3 skirmish on legendary yet?


    Signature not detected please remain calm
  •  02-14-2009, 3:40 PM 470032 in reply to 470025

    Re: My personal review of Halo Wars(the game, not the demo)

    wutz a cuvonant?

     

    Interesting enough.  I always thought the Skirmish mode would shine through above the campaign and I guess it has, good and bad.  Is "automatic 40" insanely hard, as in you couldn't do it at your very best, or is it achieveable?  (Well of course it is but you catch my drift!)

     

    Shame about canon, but oh well.  (Also did you get the normal or the le, if le what the book like?)


    1 w4n7 m¥ 1m493$ b4(|{!
  •  02-14-2009, 3:43 PM 470035 in reply to 470029

    Re: My personal review of Halo Wars(the game, not the demo)

    Hawki:

    Thanks for the review. Quite well written.

    One thing though-you mentioned something about black boxes and the Halo Timeline, the latter I recall being linked to an achievement. Is it a case of unlocking aspects of the timeline by finding these boxes, kind of like Command and Conquer 3 except unlocking info based on location rather than the completion of objectives? Or is there a different system?

    If the campaign's as you say, I'd like to keep an eye out for such things on the first playthrough.

    Anyway, thanks again.

    Black boxes open some timeline events.  Others are achieved through other things I guess.


    MY POST COUNT IS OVER 9,000!!!
    Bow before me mortals!
    banned, for no good reason. I will be back though, and I intend to kick some serious ass...
  •  02-14-2009, 3:53 PM 470041 in reply to 470029

    Re: My personal review of Halo Wars(the game, not the demo)

    So you gave it a badish review due to canon discrepencies? Pathetic. Anyway, I think I'd rather trust the opinion of a professional, unbiased writer who has played a lot more games, and has a degree from University in journalism than some guy on the forums, such as someone who works for Game Informer., who gave it 9/10.

    "This one has forgotten whether it's heatsink is over capacity. It wonders whether the criminal scum considers itself fortunate" ~ Blasto, the only Hanar Spectre.
  •  02-14-2009, 3:54 PM 470043 in reply to 470031

    Re: My personal review of Halo Wars(the game, not the demo)

    Loliaz:

    Perfect review! Nicely done Felix.

     

    Q: So ya tried the 3v3 skirmish on legendary yet?

    once, it was a total lose for me...


    MY POST COUNT IS OVER 9,000!!!
    Bow before me mortals!
    banned, for no good reason. I will be back though, and I intend to kick some serious ass...
  •  02-14-2009, 3:54 PM 470045 in reply to 470035

    Re: My personal review of Halo Wars(the game, not the demo)

    a 7 or 7.5 is quite disappointing in my books. Judging from what ive seen and played i would rate it 8.5 to 9. .

    just to get a better idea of ur rating credibility how would you rate the following games : gta4, bioshock, halo 3, gears of war 2, fable 2.

     and can u give an approximate time it took you to complete the campaign.

    thanks for writing a review.

  •  02-14-2009, 3:55 PM 470046 in reply to 470032

    Re: My personal review of Halo Wars(the game, not the demo)

    Evil Pig:

    wutz a cuvonant?

     

    Interesting enough.  I always thought the Skirmish mode would shine through above the campaign and I guess it has, good and bad.  Is "automatic 40" insanely hard, as in you couldn't do it at your very best, or is it achieveable?  (Well of course it is but you catch my drift!)

     

    Shame about canon, but oh well.  (Also did you get the normal or the le, if le what the book like?)

    I havent tried automatic 40 yet, and I assume its insane.


    MY POST COUNT IS OVER 9,000!!!
    Bow before me mortals!
    banned, for no good reason. I will be back though, and I intend to kick some serious ass...
  •  02-14-2009, 3:58 PM 470049 in reply to 470045

    Re: My personal review of Halo Wars(the game, not the demo)

    jaboma:

    a 7 or 7.5 is quite disappointing in my books. Judging from what ive seen and played i would rate it 8.5 to 9. .

    just to get a better idea of ur rating credibility how would you rate the following games : gta4, bioshock, halo 3, gears of war 2, fable 2.

     and can u give an approximate time it took you to complete the campaign.

    thanks for writing a review.

    gta 4 was a bit of a disappiontment in my books, halo wars may have copied halo 3 in the aspect of "bad campaign, just play multiplayer", havent played bioshock, gears i just didnt like, and i never played fable.

    like i said, this was a personal review, on my personal views of the game


    MY POST COUNT IS OVER 9,000!!!
    Bow before me mortals!
    banned, for no good reason. I will be back though, and I intend to kick some serious ass...
  •  02-14-2009, 4:00 PM 470052 in reply to 470025

    Re: My personal review of Halo Wars(the game, not the demo)

    Three questions:

    I know they probably aren't, and this is probably a stupid question, but are the graphics any better than in the demo?

    Are, in your opinion, the leaders balanced?

    Is the poulation cap as small as it is in the demo?

  •  02-14-2009, 4:00 PM 470053 in reply to 470041

    Re: My personal review of Halo Wars(the game, not the demo)

    Wolverfrog49:So you gave it a badish review due to canon discrepencies? Pathetic. Anyway, I think I'd rather trust the opinion of a professional, unbiased writer who has played a lot more games, and has a degree from University in journalism than some guy on the forums, such as someone who works for Game Informer., who gave it 9/10.

    Due to the fun factor. I personally believe felix more because he's not some biased "omfgz halo omfgz itz the shtisz ofmaskdm gf" type of person. And honestly if the story doesn't make that much sense then I really wouldn't give it a high score. So I'm pretty sure I would believe felix over all the people who just look at Halo for it's multiplayer.


    71180040

    The sun will never set at Ensemble Studio's.

    Missing the old halo wars forums... :-( And Paragon!

    Korther is now officially on my stupid people's list.

  •  02-14-2009, 4:00 PM 470054 in reply to 470049

    Re: My personal review of Halo Wars(the game, not the demo)

    Anyway, do we get a valid explanation as to why we encounter the Flood? No need to tell me what, just say yes or no.

    "This one has forgotten whether it's heatsink is over capacity. It wonders whether the criminal scum considers itself fortunate" ~ Blasto, the only Hanar Spectre.
  •  02-14-2009, 4:01 PM 470055 in reply to 470049

    Re: My personal review of Halo Wars(the game, not the demo)

    wat about 2nd question. how long did campaign take to complete?
Page 1 of 78 (1,159 items)   1 2 3 4 5 Next > ... Last »
View as RSS news feed in XML