playboy26:they both are first persons shooters and because they are the same genre of games it should be easy to compare to the two. the two games are both great FPS and because of that gameplay is a matter of opinion. However things like graphics and sound can have a clear winner. The sound effects in COD4 are probably the greatests sound effects in all of gaming regardless of genre and my opinion also even u agree COD4 has an edge in the graphics department.
Though they are in the same genre they are not the same. Would you compare Bioshock to Halo 3? Turok to unreal tournament?
They may have the fundamental style of a first person shooter, the story, the plotline and how you play each game is different.
I do, COD4 has very good graphics, for a realistic shooter. Not a sci-fi shooter. That title would go to Mass effect, and that's an RPG.
'For eons I have watched as you have misinterpreted. This is not Reclaimation, this is reclaimer'- Mendicant Bias
Vigil is watching you
Check out my new fan-fic: Operation Overwatch