We'll use another theory/instance:

"Smart" Theory:

Regarding the Flood on the Forerunner Shield/Shipyard World; There's absolutely NOTHING to prove that the Flood were contained solely on Installation 04 and the gas mine on Threshold. Therefore one cannot accurately say that the Flood could not possibly have been on the Shield World.

Dumb Theory:

John Forge is John-117's father. John Forge was born on Earth in 2502. John-117 was born on Eridanus II in 2511. There is no possible way that John Forge had any correlation to the Master Chief.

---

Spartan R41, prepped for combat insertion.

www.facebook.com/Spartanr41 (If sending a friend request, please also send your HWF name. Keep in mind a request accept isn't guaranteed.)

Never Forgotten: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qGh7JbFQDX4

Spartan R41:

We'll use another theory/instance:

"Smart" Theory:

Regarding the Flood on the Forerunner Shield/Shipyard World; There's absolutely NOTHING to prove that the Flood were contained solely on Installation 04 and the gas mine on Threshold. Therefore one cannot accurately say that the Flood could not possibly have been on the Shield World.

Dumb Theory:

John Forge is John-117's father. John Forge was born on Earth in 2502. John-117 was born on Eridanus II in 2511. There is no possible way that John Forge had any correlation to the Master Chief.

I understood that but i did'nt understand why ur comparing theory's one minute where on about spartans and then your talking about dumb and smart theorys care to explain how it fits in with the OP or replys or was it my reply to the other guy the reason behind your posts

---

Mouldy Cobra:Omg! thats a big ban hammer 0.0

http://www.cracked.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/haloshaft.jpg

What I meant is that there was no dates given for the Second Spartan class' creation. So for Wolverfrog to theorize that John's class wasn't the first wasn't a stupid theory.

---

Spartan R41, prepped for combat insertion.

www.facebook.com/Spartanr41 (If sending a friend request, please also send your HWF name. Keep in mind a request accept isn't guaranteed.)

Never Forgotten: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qGh7JbFQDX4

Spartan R41:What I meant is that there was no dates given for the Second Spartan class' creation. So for Wolverfrog to theorize that John's class wasn't the first wasn't a stupid theory.

ah right so it was his post not mine got ya, although im pretty sure he was being stupid considering he did'nt like this "USELESS" topic

---

Mouldy Cobra:Omg! thats a big ban hammer 0.0

http://www.cracked.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/haloshaft.jpg

Wolverfrog49:The current canon contradicts other canon. Just wait for Bungie to make Reach, all will be explained.

If bungie abort reach too, i swear to god im going to go over to their headquaters and load their heads full o lead!!!

ive read all books 2 times where has it mentioned 2 classes of spartan II's?

---

my account (my brother made the name)
Tanmanksu1000

My brothers acount i use
Topgun1017
27TS 1v1
33TS 2v2 random
15TS 3v3random
ever seen me ingame send me a msg tell me how i did or how the match went! ;)

saints:ive read all books 2 times where has it mentioned 2 classes of spartan II's?

In a side section somewhere, it tells us that a second program was established, i think named sparten II:II 

it means sparten project 2, perversion 2

AHTFrigate:

saints:ive read all books 2 times where has it mentioned 2 classes of spartan II's?

In a side section somewhere, it tells us that a second program was established, i think named sparten II:II 

it means sparten project 2, perversion 2

Read about spartan II project on halopedia it'll tell you what book or source its from and tell you about the project

---

Mouldy Cobra:Omg! thats a big ban hammer 0.0

http://www.cracked.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/haloshaft.jpg

saints:ive read all books 2 times where has it mentioned 2 classes of spartan II's?

The second class is mentioned in Ghosts of Onyx, as well as the Halo 2 viral campaign "I Love Bees."

---

Spartan R41, prepped for combat insertion.

www.facebook.com/Spartanr41 (If sending a friend request, please also send your HWF name. Keep in mind a request accept isn't guaranteed.)

Never Forgotten: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qGh7JbFQDX4

Paulus Magintie:

Spartan R41:What I meant is that there was no dates given for the Second Spartan class' creation. So for Wolverfrog to theorize that John's class wasn't the first wasn't a stupid theory.

ah right so it was his post not mine got ya, although im pretty sure he was being stupid considering he did'nt like this "USELESS" topic

 :/

---

Below all available in the Library forum.

Halo 3: Insurrection - The stunning epilogue to Halo 3.

Memoirs of an ODST - Partake upon an epic adventure though the eyes of one who saw it all.

Halo: True Sangheili - Scholar one day, soldier the next.

There were no Spartans alive after Halo Wars. They all died in my skirmish game, but I took down that Prophet 12 times!

@Sarcasm

---

Christian, Conservative, Republican. In that Order. -Mike Pence, Indiana Congressman

Death to the WaffenSS!

www.Micom.net/oops = The funniest pictures I've seen in a WHILE!!

Wolverfrog49:

Paulus Magintie:

Spartan R41:What I meant is that there was no dates given for the Second Spartan class' creation. So for Wolverfrog to theorize that John's class wasn't the first wasn't a stupid theory.

ah right so it was his post not mine got ya, although im pretty sure he was being stupid considering he did'nt like this "USELESS" topic

 :/

after re-reading what spartan said i relize the last bit was wrong wolverfrog said something about john not being on the 1st group of spartans and yet spartan r41 said it was'nt a stupid theory so both of ya are wrong on in those 2 posts and sorry if i offended ya wolverfrog its not intended its just a figure of speech u just happen 2 say the wrong thing at the wrong time or word summert wrong

everybody knows john was in the 1st class of spartan IIs the 2nd class had trouble finding suitable subjects because of the war going on when john was already fighting the war when the 2nd class was being trained

---

Mouldy Cobra:Omg! thats a big ban hammer 0.0

http://www.cracked.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/haloshaft.jpg

Spartan R41:What I meant is that there was no dates given for the Second Spartan class' creation. So for Wolverfrog to theorize that John's class wasn't the first wasn't a stupid theory.

John's was the first. It is stated in Ghosts of Onyx "(Kurt's thought's after Ackerson tells him that SPRTN II PRGM funds were...diverted)It turned out they may be the first and last SPARTAN-IIs"

---

Whenever a thread has been hijacked and there are big quote boxes and lots of flame, I'll be there!

I'll be off playing ACII for a couple weeks...

The Spartan II second class was eventually initiated in 2537. The funds were diverted in 2531 to the Spartan III program, most likely by Ackerson.

---

Spartan R41, prepped for combat insertion.

www.facebook.com/Spartanr41 (If sending a friend request, please also send your HWF name. Keep in mind a request accept isn't guaranteed.)

Never Forgotten: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qGh7JbFQDX4

To my surprise, more Spartans are alive than I thought

---

Halo Return of the Covenant. Chapter 4 Up
http://www.halowars.com/forums/thread/751939.aspx
UNSC and Covenant Factions remade v2. Infantry Poll up
http://www.halowars.com/forums/734015/ShowThread.aspx#734015